How to choose malpractice insurance limits for surgeons
Medical Malpractice Insurance for Physicians with Prior Claims: What You Need to Know
If you are a physician with a prior malpractice claim on your record, you already know how difficult it can be to find affordable, reliable coverage. Many standard insurance carriers will decline your application outright or offer premiums so high that they become financially unsustainable. But having a claims history does not mean you are uninsurable — it simply means you need to work with a specialist who understands your situation.
At Island Insurance Group, we specialize in helping physicians with prior claims history secure the medical malpractice coverage they need to continue practicing with confidence. Our team understands the nuances of high-risk medical malpractice insurance in Florida, and we work with a broad network of carriers who are specifically willing to underwrite physicians with complex histories.
Why Prior Claims Make Coverage More Challenging
Insurance carriers view prior malpractice claims as an indicator of future risk. Even if a claim was dismissed, settled without fault, or resolved years ago, it can still significantly impact your ability to obtain coverage. Carriers look at several factors when evaluating a physician with claims history, including:
- The number of claims filed against you
- The nature and severity of the alleged incidents
- Whether claims resulted in settlements or verdicts
- The amounts paid out on prior claims
- Your medical specialty and its inherent risk profile
- Your current practice setting and patient volume
Standard market carriers often use automated screening tools that immediately flag physicians with any claims history. This is where working with a specialized agency like Island Insurance Group becomes essential. We go beyond the automated screens and present your full story to underwriters who are experienced in evaluating complex risk profiles.
How Island Insurance Group Helps High-Risk Physicians
Our licensed agent, Samuel Bennett, has extensive experience navigating the excess and surplus lines market, which is where many high-risk physicians ultimately find their best coverage options. Samuel works directly with non-admitted carriers and specialty markets that are designed to accommodate physicians who have been turned away by standard insurers.
When you work with Samuel and the Island Insurance Group team, you can expect a thorough, personalized approach that includes:
- A detailed review of your claims history and documentation
- Strategic presentation of your file to multiple specialty carriers
- Explanation of your coverage options, including claims-made and occurrence policies
- Guidance on tail coverage if you are transitioning between positions or retiring
- Ongoing support to ensure your coverage evolves with your practice
We believe that every physician deserves the opportunity to practice medicine without fear of being left unprotected. One or even multiple past claims does not define your entire career, and we are committed to finding carriers who see the full picture.
Understanding Your Policy Options
Physicians with prior claims often have questions about whether to pursue a claims-made policy or an occurrence policy. Claims-made policies cover incidents that are both reported and occurred during the active policy period, while occurrence policies cover any incident that occurred during the policy period regardless of when it is reported. Each has advantages and trade-offs, particularly when prior claims are involved. Samuel Bennett can walk you through the specific implications of each policy type based on your unique history and practice needs.
Take Advantage of Our Free Assessment Tool
Not sure where to start? Island Insurance Group offers a free resource to help small business owners and medical professionals evaluate their coverage needs. Visit our free small business insurance assessment tool to get a clearer picture of your current coverage gaps and where you may need additional protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get medical malpractice insurance if I have multiple claims?
Yes. While multiple claims will require placement in specialty or surplus lines markets, coverage is still available. The key is working with an agent experienced in high-risk medical malpractice placement.
Will my premium always be higher because of past claims?
In most cases, yes. However, the amount of the increase depends on the details of your claims history. Some situations are less impactful than others, and a skilled agent can negotiate on your behalf.
Do I need tail coverage if I am switching carriers?
If you are on a claims-made policy, tail coverage is almost always necessary when changing insurers to ensure you remain protected for past incidents.
How long does it take to get coverage arranged?
For high-risk physicians, the placement process can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks depending on carrier response times and the complexity of your history.
Book Your Consultation Today
You do not have to navigate the complex world of high-risk medical malpractice insurance alone. Samuel Bennett and the Island Insurance Group team are ready to help you find the coverage you need at the most competitive rates available. Book a free 30-minute consultation today and take the first step toward securing your practice and your future.