If You Refuse to Settle a Malpractice Claim, Who Pays What Happens Next?
If You Refuse to Settle a Malpractice Claim, Who Pays What Happens Next?
Before You Say Yes
By Samuel Bennett, Licensed Insurance Agent, Island Insurance Group
Your malpractice insurer recommends settling for $250,000. You believe your care was appropriate and want to defend it. Your policy gives you the right to refuse. Before you answer, find out what the insurer would still pay the day after you say no.
Would you take the settlement?
Fictional case. The insurer recommends an available settlement of $250,000 The same physician, claim, offer, and $1 million per-claim limit apply in both policy examples.
Choose one option below to see your result.
Reveal the two policy outcomes
Assume the physician declines, a $500,000 covered judgment follows, and the defense costs $40,000 before the recommendation and $90,000 afterward. Assume a covered claim, no deductible, and otherwise covered defense expenses paid outside the $1 million limit, subject to the illustrated cap.
A. Consent without this cap
Refusing the offer does not reduce what the insurer pays in this example. It pays $500,000 in judgment and $130,000 in defense.
- Insurer pays
- $630,000
- Physician pays in this model
- $0
B. Consent with a hammer clause
In this example the carrier pays up to the rejected offer plus defense expenses incurred before the recommendation. It pays $250,000 toward the judgment and $40,000 toward defense.
- Insurer pays
- $290,000
- Physician’s modeled share
- $340,000
Where the $340,000 comes from: $250,000 of the judgment above the offer plus $90,000 in post-recommendation defense costs. These are illustrative policy terms and arithmetic for one outcome. The case could end differently, and actual wording governs.
Consent and the cost of saying no
The consent provision tells you whose approval the insurer needs to settle. The financial terms tell you what may happen after a refusal. MedPro describes one form of hammer clause that caps the insurer’s obligation at what the claim could have settled for, plus expenses incurred before the insurer recommended settlement. Its guide also identifies other consent exceptions, such as review-panel approval or arbitration. The declarations page can show the same $1 million limit in both examples while the policy wording produces a very different result. MedPro guide to consent-to-settle exceptions (PDF)
If a physician and practice entity are insured together, check whose consent counts and whether that changes when both are named. Read the settlement provision alongside the defense-expense language and endorsements. Search for phrases such as refuse to consent, recommended settlement, and claim expenses. Ask for the page and endorsement number when you get an answer.
Send this question before your next renewal
If I decline a settlement the insurer recommends, how does my policy allocate defense costs incurred after the recommendation and any later judgment or settlement? Please point me to the policy wording and any endorsement that changes it.
For an active claim, discuss the offer and deadlines with your claims representative and defense counsel. This example is designed for comparing policy language.
Island Insurance Group helps physicians and medical practices compare malpractice insurance terms. If you have a specific clause to review, schedule a coverage conversation. You can also explore our insurance tools.
Samuel Bennett
Licensed Insurance Agent, Island Insurance Group
954-804-8144
sam@islandinsurancegroup.com
